Facing Facebook

Rheingold’s social-media class did an exercise that changed the way many of his students interact with Facebook.

Each student projected their profile on a screen with everything but their name or picture. Everyone had to guess whose profile was on display. Estela Marie Go, an undergraduate student in the class, says she suddenly realized that she didn’t like the way Facebook forced her to define herself with a list of interests.
Sydell (2010) on NPR.

A number of my students have Facebook accounts. I have one too, but I think I’ve used it twice in the year that I’ve had it. Part of my problem is about how it accelerates the loss of privacy inherent to living on the net. However, I also have a very big problem with its insular nature, the fact that it is its own walled-off section of the internet. The two times I’ve used it have been when people I knew from inside the wall wanted to share something and I could not get to it from outside. I also find it difficult to give so much personal information, about my history and my habits to a single company.

So I’m always enthused to see other people coming to the same conclusions, like those in NPR’s recently broadcast story about how, “New Networks Target Discomfort With Facebook.”

Blocking Wikipedia

From Wikimedia Commons

It’s not as much of an issue in science (Natural World) but because it tends to pop up to the top of the search engines, my students tend to overuse Wikipedia, so I’m considering, at least as an experiment, blocking it. Wikipedia tends to be reliable in general, but its open nature, where anyone can edit also means that it can also be spectacularly wrong.

I use, and I encourage my students to use Wikipedia for two things, finding images that are not restrictively copyrighted (almost all images on Wikipedia are free for anyone to use since that is a specific part of their policy), and finding, at the bottom of the articles, the list of references to what are usually credible sources for the topic they are researching. While this seems to work well for science research, because Wikipedia’s articles tend to be too technical for middle schoolers, some of my students have been burned when using Wikipedia articles as a reference for their social world projects.

So I’m going to try blocking Wikipedia for a week and see what happens. Students can still use Wikimedia Commons for images, but they’ll have to find sources in other ways.